Short circuits and open circuits

Debug · 10 min

Circuits fail in two basic ways. A path that should be there is broken: an open circuit. Or a path that shouldn't be there has appeared: a short circuit. You can find both with a voltmeter and the laws you already know.

This board has three 1 kΩ resistors in series across 9 V. If all were well:

Should be
Current9 V ÷ 3 kΩ = 3 mA
Across each resistor3 V

Press Run and watch for the moving dots.

Think before measuring. No current flows, so by Ohm's law each good resistor has V=0×R = 0 V across it.

But Kirchhoff's voltage law still holds: the voltages around the loop must add up to the battery's 9 V. So what is the voltage across the broken resistor?

  • 0 V, like the others
  • 3 V, its usual share
  • 9 V, the whole supply

Find it. Measure the voltage across each of the three resistors in turn. Which one is open?

  • The left one
  • The middle one
  • The right one

Replace the broken resistor: delete it, and put a new 1 kΩ from the drawer in its place.

A second board, built the same way, with a different fault. Press Run.

A shorted resistor behaves like a plain wire, with almost no resistance. The current through it isn't zero this time. So what voltage do you expect across it?

  • About 0 V
  • 3 V, its usual share
  • 9 V, the whole supply

Measure across each resistor again. Which one is shorted?

  • The left one
  • The middle one
  • The right one

Replace the shorted resistor with a new 1 kΩ from the drawer.

Both faults put 0 V across some parts, so a single reading isn't enough:

Open circuitShort circuit
Current in the loopnonemore than normal
Across the faulty partthe whole supply0 V
Across the good parts0 Vmore than normal

A string of four lamps in series has gone dark. Across one of the lamps you measure the full supply voltage; across each of the others, 0 V. What has happened?

  • The lamp with the full voltage across it has gone open
  • The lamp with the full voltage across it is shorted
  • The three lamps reading 0 V are all shorted

What you've found:

  • An open circuit stops the current. In a series loop, the whole supply voltage appears across the break.
  • A short circuit has no voltage across it, and the current goes up, because there's less resistance left in the loop.
  • Compare each reading with what it should be. The part whose voltage is wrong in the telling way is the faulty one.

One short deserves special respect: a short straight across the supply. Then there is nothing left in the loop to limit the current. A battery gets hot, a bench supply shuts down, and mains wiring blows its fuse, which is the job fuses are for.

On a real bench most "open circuits" aren't broken parts. They're a leg that isn't pushed fully into the board, a wire in the wrong row, or a broken wire inside its insulation. Most shorts are two bare legs touching. The method is the same: measure, compare with what you expect, and close in.