Why each parallel LED gets its own resistor

Lab · 9 min

In the last lesson, each parallel LED had its own resistor. That looks wasteful. Why not let two LEDs share one?

Somebody has tried it here. They wanted 15 mA in each of two red LEDs, so 30 mA in all, and worked out one resistor for the pair: (9 − 2.0) V ÷ 30 mA ≈ 220 Ω. A yellow wire joins the two LEDs' long legs, and each LED's short leg goes back to the − rail through a meter set to amps.

Press Run.

Both LEDs are the same type, out of the same bag. About 30 mA is flowing through the resistor. How do you expect it to divide between the two LEDs?

  • Equally: 15 mA each
  • Nearly equally: within a milliamp or so
  • Very unequally: one takes most of it

Find out. Press Record a reading to note the current through each LED.

Why it happens

No two LEDs are quite identical. Their forward voltages differ by a few hundredths of a volt, even within one batch. These two differ by 0.2 V.

Remember the LED's curve from Non-ohmic parts: almost nothing until its forward voltage, then very steeply upwards. On a curve that steep, a tiny change in voltage is a huge change in current.

Now, what does wiring two LEDs directly in parallel force to be the same for both?

  • Their currents
  • The voltage across them
  • Their brightness

The cure is to stop forcing the two LEDs to the same voltage. Give each its own resistor:

  1. Delete the yellow wire.
  2. Add a second resistor for the right-hand LED, fed by its own wire from the + rail.
  3. Each resistor now supplies one LED, not two, so each needs to be about twice as big: set both to 470 Ω.

Each LED should end up between 13 and 17 mA.

Press Record a reading once more and compare the two LEDs now.

Three LEDs are to run from 5 V, each at 10 mA. Which is the sound way to wire them?

  • All three in parallel, sharing one resistor sized for 30 mA
  • Each with its own resistor sized for 10 mA, and the three branches in parallel
  • All three in parallel with no resistor: 5 V isn't much

What you've found:

  • LEDs wired directly in parallel are forced to the same voltage, and their currents come out wildly different.
  • A resistor per LED (or per series chain of LEDs) lets each branch settle at its own voltage and sets its current.
  • The rule: never share one resistor between parallel LEDs.

Going deeper

It gets worse as the circuit warms up. The LED carrying more current runs hotter, and an LED's forward voltage falls as it heats. So the hog's share grows, which heats it further. This feedback is called thermal runaway, and with high-power LEDs it ends with the hog burning out, after which the next LED takes over the whole current and follows it.

On a real bench you'll see cheap torches with a dozen LEDs in parallel and no resistors at all, relying on the battery's own resistance. They work, roughly, because the LEDs are from one batch and the makers don't mind uneven brightness or a short life.