The 10× rule

Design · 11 min

A load pulls a divider's output down. How far depends on how the load compares with the divider's own resistors, so a designer's question is: how small must the divider be for its output to hold?

Here is a divider feeding a 10 kΩ load. Its two resistors are kept equal, so with no load it gives 4.5 V. Slide their size up and down and watch what the load does to the output, and what the divider costs in current.

Find a size where the output sags by less than 5% and the divider wastes no more than 10 mA.

The 10× rule

What you found is a rule of thumb used everywhere:

Make the load's resistance at least ten times the divider's bottom resistor.

Said the other way round: the current flowing down the divider should be at least ten times the current the load takes. Then the load's share is small change, and the output sags by a few percent: about 5% for a divider of two equal resistors, and never more than 9%.

A divider that holds its voltage like this is called stiff.

Divider's R2, against a 10 kΩ loadSagCurrent wasted (two equal resistors, 9 V)
10 kΩ, the same as the load33%0.45 mA
1 kΩ, a tenth4.8%4.5 mA
100 Ω, a hundredth0.5%45 mA

Each tenfold improvement in stiffness costs ten times the current. That is the trade-off.

A sensor's output must feed a load of 100 kΩ through a divider. By the 10× rule, what is the largest bottom resistor the divider should have?

Answer in Ω.

Now design one. The resistor already on the board, from column 20 to the − rail, is a 10 kΩ load. It needs 4.5 V.

Build a divider across the 9 V battery and wire its output to the load's column. Your divider must:

  • give between 4.275 V and 4.725 V (4.5 V ± 5%) with the load connected;
  • stay in that range if the load is unplugged;
  • draw no more than 15 mA from the battery.

The drawer's resistors come in preferred values from 100 Ω to 100 kΩ.

Suppose the load were a small motor that behaves like 100 Ω, and it still needs 4.5 V from the 9 V battery.

By the 10× rule the divider's resistors would have to be about 10 Ω each. What would that divider draw from the battery, all the time, whether the motor ran or not?

Answer in A.

So which of these is a sensible job for a resistor divider?

  • Scaling a 12 V battery's voltage down to under 5 V so a chip's high-resistance input can measure it
  • Running a 5 V motor from a 12 V supply
  • Charging a phone from a 9 V battery

The 10× rule:

  • keep the load at least ten times the divider's bottom resistor, and the output holds within a few percent;
  • a stiffer divider wastes more current: ten times stiffer, ten times the current;
  • so a design is squeezed between sag (resistors too big) and waste (resistors too small);
  • dividers suit light loads. They are the wrong tool for delivering power.

On a real bench the inputs of chips and meters are often 1 MΩ or more, which is why dividers of 10 kΩ to 100 kΩ work so often without anyone thinking about it.